Towns · Caledonia County
Sheffield
Short on great men, its historian admitted. Long on bears.
Sheffield's first historian was candid. No lawyer, he reported, had ever yet resided in town, and the town had never been prolific in what the world calls great men. He made up for it with bears. One came into a cabin at midnight and walked across the bed of a young couple, who took it for a dog. The husband grabbed it by the hind leg. The bear, as frightened as anyone, left by the door.
A man named Bruce once built a sawmill at the outlet of a pond, got it running, then suddenly removed the machinery and left the country. The pond got his name, which is more than he asked for.
In 1937 a guidebook found the old church on the hill opened once a year, for Old Home Day. The 1829 Freewill Baptist church on Berry Hill still holds one every August, according to the town plan. Sixteen wind turbines have turned on the northwest ridge since 2011, approved at a special town meeting by 120 votes to 93.
The Town in Figures
- People
- 573
- Land
- 32.8 square miles
- People per square mile
- 17.5
- Median age
- 42.0
- Homes lived in year-roundHomes with someone in them all year, out of all homes
- 69%
- Homes used for part of the yearCamps, second homes and the like
- 27%
U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–24, and 2023 land area. Estimates for small towns carry wide margins.
The Roads
- Public road
- 59 miles
- Paved
- 16 miles
- DirtGravel, graded earth and unimproved road
- 43 miles
- Share that is dirt
- 73%
Vermont Agency of Transportation, highway surface report, 2022. Whole miles, approximate; interstate, state and town highways.
Town Meeting
- Town officers chosen by Australian ballot
- No
- Town budget voted by Australian ballot
- No
- Public questions voted by Australian ballot
- Yes
- Registered voters, 2026
- 516
- Voted by ballot, 2026Including absentee ballots
- 88 (17%)
The town clerk's answers to the Vermont Secretary of State, for the 2026 annual meeting (turnout: the newest year the clerk gave a usable count). Australian ballot is a paper ballot at the polls; where a town does not use it, the vote is taken from the floor at the meeting, and cities with a council set some of this by charter.
The School
- Millers Run SchoolKingdom East Unified Union School District #64Grades pre-K to 8, 146 students
National Center for Education Statistics, Common Core of Data, 2024. Schools in the town only: many Vermont towns send some or all of their students to a school in another town, and this list does not say which.
Getting to Work
- Work from homeOut of everyone who works
- 6%
- Under 15 minutes to workOut of those who travel to work
- 18%
- 45 minutes or moreOut of those who travel to work
- 12%
U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–24. Estimates for small towns carry wide margins.
The Weather
- Yearly snowfallMeasured at Sutton, 3.7 miles away
- 142 inches
- Average winter lowDecember to February
- 8°F
- Average summer highJune to August
- 74°F
- Yearly average temperature
- 41°F
- Yearly precipitationRain and melted snow
- 48 inches
NOAA 1991–2020 climate normals. These are the figures of the weather station at Sutton, 3.7 miles away and 1,500 feet above sea level, not measurements in the town itself.
Taxes and Prices
- Education tax rate, homesteadsProperty tax for schools on a home you live in, 2026–27 tax year
- $1.7985 per $100
- Education tax rate, other propertySecond homes, rentals and businesses
- $1.8844 per $100
- Median home valueWhat owners say their homes are worth, not sale prices
- $171,900
- Median rent
- $967 a month
- Median household income
- $58,333
- Homes lived in by their ownersOut of homes lived in year-round
- 84%
U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–24. Education tax rates: Vermont Department of Taxes, FY2027 table (July 29, 2026), after the common level of appraisal. The town’s own municipal rate is not included.
Compare Sheffield with another town
Also in Caledonia County
Barnet · Burke · Danville · Groton · Hardwick · Kirby · Lyndon · Newark · Peacham · Ryegate · St. Johnsbury · Stannard · Sutton · Walden · Waterford · Wheelock